Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes

Born in San Francisco on December 28, 1939
If you’re like me, then likely you don’t recognize the name Jake Holmes. If you’re like me, likely you would immediately recognize his words.
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
A History of Rock Music in 500 Songs

Let’s first give someone the kudos he well deserves for inspiring this post: Andrew Hickey.
From the books2read.com site: “He is the author of (at the time of writing) over twenty books, ranging from novels of the occult to reference books on 1960s Doctor Who serials. In his spare time he is a musician and perennial third-placed political candidate.”
And he is the person behind the “A History of Rock Music in 500 Songs” podcast. The show’s intent is to analyze the history of rock and roll music, from its origins in swing, Western swing, boogie woogie, and gospel, through to the 1990s, grunge, and Britpop.
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
Jake Holmes
Hinkey’s song #187 is “Dazed and Confused.” If like me, Led Zeppelin immediately comes to mind, you’d be both right and wrong.
Jake Holmes wrote “Dazed and Confused” but not but maybe the one Jimmy Page brought to his new band and became one of the band’s staples.
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
Comedy
But let’s back up a bit.
Holmes, like many young musicians, had a varied career. He started out in comedy. Holmes and his then-wife formed a comedy duo: Allen & Grier, they released one album, It’s Better to Be Rich Than Ethnic in 1963.
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
The Thorns
He and his wife split up ending the group. Among the musicians Holmes then found himself with was Tim Rose and Rich Husson. They called themselves The Thorns and they covered a then unknown song call, “Hey Joe.”
While in the Thorns, there was an interesting encounter that none realized was so influential.
In Fort William, Ontario, they met a The Squires, a Canadian band. In that band was one Neil Young. The Thorns style showed Young that there was interesting stuff being done on the fringes of the folk music scene. He later said “One of my favourites was “Oh Susannah”—they did this arrangement that was bizarre. It was in a minor key, which completely changed everything—and it was rock and roll. So that idea spawned arrangements of all these other songs for me. I did minor versions of them all. We got into it. That was a certain Squires stage that never got recorded. Wish there were tapes of those shows. We used to do all this stuff, a whole kinda music—folk-rock. We took famous old folk songs like “Clementine,” “She’ll Be Comin’ ’Round the Mountain,” “Tom Dooley,” and we did them all in minor keys based on the Tim Rose arrangement of “Oh Susannah.” (quote from Episode 152 of 500 Songs)
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
Back to Comedy
Holmes quit that act and formed a comedy folk trio: Jim, Jake, and Joan. The group broke up because Joan insisted on wearing a Republican button at a Robert F Kennedy senatorial campaign in 1964.
Joan was Joan Rivers, so that worked out OK.
Jim was Jim Connell who became a bit actor.
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
Back to Music
Holmes joined another group, but left it to become a singer-songwriter with jazz guitarist Ted Irwin and bass player Rick Randle. With the success of singer-songwriters like John Lennon and Paul McCartney, many musicians read the writing on that proverbial wall.
In 1967, he released his debut album, The “Above Ground” Sound of Jake Holmes, including the single “Genuine Imitation Life.”
It didn’t sell.
And All-Music review today states: Holmes’ thin voice was recorded in a way that makes it sound curiously muffled and disembodied, which both adds to the weirdness of the weirder parts and detracts from the record’s overall power. His songwriting, too, is erratic, sometimes reaching a reasonably effective level of haunting loneliness, at others descending into bathos (particularly on the closer, “Signs of Age”).
A Letter to Katherine December
From the podcast’s transcript: Holmes followed The “Above Ground” Sound with a second album, again featuring Irwin but no longer featuring Randle, who had had mental health problems and eventually refused to get on a plane. That one, A Letter to Katherine December, a collection of songs mostly about the breakdown of Holmes’ marriage, is generally considered his greatest, and is very much in the same mould as albums like Astral Weeks, Forever Changes, and the early work of Tim Buckley, combining light orchestration, eccentric folk-style melodies, and jazz guitar.
It sold no better than the first.
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
Recognition Success
While his albums did not sell well, other musicians liked Holmes’s songs. When the trio opened for the Youngbloods and the Yardbirds in Greenwich Village in late 1967, they impressed the Yardbirds who went out and bought The Above Ground…
And not only did they like the songs, they began to cover one of Holmes’s songs on that album.
When Yardbird Jimmy Page left and formed Led Zeppelin, he brought the idea of Dazed and Confused with him. I say “the idea” because while both Page’s and Holmes’s songs sound very similar, Page used new lyrics and credited the song to himself.
That thorn will stay in Holmes’s side for years.
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
The Four Seasons!?
Another person who liked Holmes’s music was Bob Gaudio.
Gaudio, had been the Royal Teens’ keyboard player (he had co-written their hit song “Short Shorts).
In early 1960, Gaudio left the Teens and joined the Four Lovers with lead singer Frankie Valli. The Lovers later changed their name to the Four Seasons.
Valli and Gaudio agreed between themselves that the two of them, as lead singer and songwriter respectively, would actually be the Four Seasons legally.
A string of hits followed.
Sherry, Big Girls Don’t Cry, Walk Like a Man, and Rag Doll. The only more successful American band at the time were the Beach Boys.
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
Damn Beatles
Then came the Beatles and the British Invasion and singers who covered songs found it hard to compete with singers who sang their own songs, especially with the constant successes of the Beatles.
Gaudio thought of Holmes and together wrote an entire album of songs for the Four Seasons, entitled Genuine Imitation Life Gazette in an attempt to capture the new sounds.
It was a failure compared to other Four Seasons albums because their teen-pop audience didn’t want psychedelic satirical records with orchestrations while the audience for that kind of material didn’t want it from the Four Seasons.
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
Frank Sinatra?!
Ol’ Blue Eyes Frank Sinatra wasn’t immune to the new sounds’ successes of these youthful unkempt musicians.
NJ Frankie Vallie and NJ Frank Sinatra had become friends and through that friendship Holmes and Gaudio wrote an entire concept album for Sinatra and only later realized that Sinatra only been expecting to get a song or two.
Yet, Sinatra chose to record the entire album, and it became the most remarkable record of Sinatra’s career.
Hinkey: The album, titled Watertown, was conceived with the expectation that it would go along with a TV special, which seems to have been planned at one point, and the opening title track works to set the scene — one can imagine the visuals as a camera tracks in from a distant shot of the town itself to Sinatra, alone, singing, on a railway station platform.
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
Holmes Back to Musician
Holmes went back to solo recording, but never had much more success as a performer. He did have some success as a songwriter though. His next solo album, So Close, So Very Far to Go was a minor success, though Holmes’s songs continued to attract the ears of other musicians such as Freddie Starr, Mary Travers, and Harry Belafonte.
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
Jingles
When a musician’s successes are limited and sporadic, they will often find other ways of using their talents.
For Jake Holmes, he found the commercial jingle niche.
Here are three of them and if you are “of a certain age” (I looking at you Boomers), you will immediately recognize them.
“I’m a Pepper” (co-written with Randy Newman)
The Army’s “Be All You Can Be”
And Gillette’s “The Best a Man Can Get”
Dazed and Confused Jake Holmes
Suits Settled
Holmes was always and, it seems to me, legitimately miffed by Led Zeppelin’s/Jimmy Page’s cover his Holmes’s “Dazed and Confused,” but for years, Holmes declined to take issue even reportedly remarking at one point, “I said, ‘What the hell, let him have it.’”
In 2010, he did finally file a copyright infringement lawsuit against Page, and the case was ultimately settled out of court
From a 2025 Rolling Stone article: As part of the settlement agreement, the songwriting credit for Led Zeppelin’s version of “Dazed and Confused” was reworked to be “inspired by Jake Holmes.” And while Holmes retained full ownership over the copyright to his original composition, it’s unclear if the settlement stipulated how any Yardbirds recordings of “Dazed and Confused” should be credited.
![]() |
![]() |
The Yardbirds side created another suit. From a 2025 Music Business Worldwide article: Singer-songwriter Jake Holmes and Led Zeppelin guitarist Jimmy Page have settled their latest copyright dispute over Dazed and Confused, according to a US court filing made on Friday (August 1).
The agreement “resolves the entire case” between the parties, though terms remain undisclosed.
Holmes had filed the lawsuit in California in May, alleging that Page violated a 2011 settlement agreement that acknowledged Holmes as the original composer of Dazed and Confused.
The complaint centered on recently released Yardbirds recordings and their inclusion in the documentary Becoming Led Zeppelin.
The latest legal action stemmed from Holmes’ claim that Page had released archival Yardbirds recordings featuring performances of the song without proper credit or compensation.









